Attitude of Medical Students towards Mentally Ill Patients: Impact of Clinical Psychiatric Rotation
Hagar Hamdy Abdel-Hameid Kandeil;
Abstract
Mental health is an essential component of health, mental
disorders can affect not only individual quality of life but also
national productivity (Wang et al., 2013). It is an ignored
subject in the field of medicine. This neglect accounts for
students’ lack of interest in psychiatry and fewer medical
students consider psychiatry as a career choice as compared to
other medical subspecialties (Aslam et al., 2009).
There is a growing concern about mental health literacy,
Jorm found that members of the public from many countries
have poor mental health literacy, which could have widespread
implications for clinical care, including lack of adherence to
evidence-based mental health care and help-seeking behaviors
(Furnham et al., 2008). Mental disorders are common,
widespread and are becoming major contributors to the global
burden of disease (GBD) (Abd Malik-Chia, 2012).
Many of them suffer alone and in silence, many never
receive treatment of any kind. Between them and the prospect
of care stand the barriers of stigma, prejudice, shame and
exclusion (Arboleda-Florez and Sartorius, 2008). In Egypt,
one of the most commonly cited reasons for the under-use of
available psychiatric services by the lay-public is the notion of
stigma (Coker, 2005), signs of mental health problems may be
ignored by the patient and the patient's family, resulting in a
delay in seeking professional help (Furnham et al., 2008).
Furnham and colleagues found also that supernatural
explanations, such as witchcraft and possession by evil spirits,
are often used in non-Western cultures to explain the etiology
of mental disorders, but this is not common in the West.
Patients may wear a protective charm called a “Tavees”, which
may constitute holy verses from the Quran, and is used as a
defense mechanism against witchcraft (Furnham et al., 2008).
_______________________________ Introduction________
2
However, psychiatry as a discipline is often perceived as
‘different’ by other medical professionals as much as by a
common man. This perception of ‘difference’ may give rise to
stigma both towards mental illness and to mental health
professionals. Mental health professionals are thus both
recipients of stigma and agents who can de-stigmatize
psychiatry (Kalra, 2012).
Psychiatry as medical specialty seems to be losing its
appeal. At the end of World War II, between 7-10% of
medicine majors in the United States used to choose psychiatry
as a career. Two different reasons have been presented as
explanations. Either medicine students nowadays are less
attracted to psychiatry in comparison with other alternatives,
or their experience while taking the undergraduate course was
unsatisfactory and this led to their rejection of that specialty
(Ortiz et al., 2010). For decades psychiatrists have been
subjected to jokes and ridicule because of their seemingly
mysterious and incomprehensive ways of understanding the
human mind and human passions (Okasha, 1995).
Goffman, in his classic 1963 work, defined
disorders can affect not only individual quality of life but also
national productivity (Wang et al., 2013). It is an ignored
subject in the field of medicine. This neglect accounts for
students’ lack of interest in psychiatry and fewer medical
students consider psychiatry as a career choice as compared to
other medical subspecialties (Aslam et al., 2009).
There is a growing concern about mental health literacy,
Jorm found that members of the public from many countries
have poor mental health literacy, which could have widespread
implications for clinical care, including lack of adherence to
evidence-based mental health care and help-seeking behaviors
(Furnham et al., 2008). Mental disorders are common,
widespread and are becoming major contributors to the global
burden of disease (GBD) (Abd Malik-Chia, 2012).
Many of them suffer alone and in silence, many never
receive treatment of any kind. Between them and the prospect
of care stand the barriers of stigma, prejudice, shame and
exclusion (Arboleda-Florez and Sartorius, 2008). In Egypt,
one of the most commonly cited reasons for the under-use of
available psychiatric services by the lay-public is the notion of
stigma (Coker, 2005), signs of mental health problems may be
ignored by the patient and the patient's family, resulting in a
delay in seeking professional help (Furnham et al., 2008).
Furnham and colleagues found also that supernatural
explanations, such as witchcraft and possession by evil spirits,
are often used in non-Western cultures to explain the etiology
of mental disorders, but this is not common in the West.
Patients may wear a protective charm called a “Tavees”, which
may constitute holy verses from the Quran, and is used as a
defense mechanism against witchcraft (Furnham et al., 2008).
_______________________________ Introduction________
2
However, psychiatry as a discipline is often perceived as
‘different’ by other medical professionals as much as by a
common man. This perception of ‘difference’ may give rise to
stigma both towards mental illness and to mental health
professionals. Mental health professionals are thus both
recipients of stigma and agents who can de-stigmatize
psychiatry (Kalra, 2012).
Psychiatry as medical specialty seems to be losing its
appeal. At the end of World War II, between 7-10% of
medicine majors in the United States used to choose psychiatry
as a career. Two different reasons have been presented as
explanations. Either medicine students nowadays are less
attracted to psychiatry in comparison with other alternatives,
or their experience while taking the undergraduate course was
unsatisfactory and this led to their rejection of that specialty
(Ortiz et al., 2010). For decades psychiatrists have been
subjected to jokes and ridicule because of their seemingly
mysterious and incomprehensive ways of understanding the
human mind and human passions (Okasha, 1995).
Goffman, in his classic 1963 work, defined
Other data
| Title | Attitude of Medical Students towards Mentally Ill Patients: Impact of Clinical Psychiatric Rotation | Authors | Hagar Hamdy Abdel-Hameid Kandeil | Issue Date | 2014 |
Recommend this item
Similar Items from Core Recommender Database
Items in Ain Shams Scholar are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.